Yes, I am a Filipino!
And I should not be the one making this review or comparison.
But I have visited both the beaches in Phuket, Thailand and in El Nido, Palawan, Philippines. And I will objectively give my comments/ranking of the two renowned beaches in the world.
I will simply select which is better in terms of the following criteria and I will also try to explain why I chose it.
1. Beach - El Nido
The best in the Philippines according to CNN for 2012.
2. Island Hopping Adventures - El Nido
It's the mode of transportation.
3. Lunch at the islands - El Nido
4. Lagoons - El Nido
(Big Lagoon, Secret and Small Lagoon)
5. Diving - El Nido
El Nido is a marine sanctuary, one of the best in the world.
6. Snorkeling and kayaking adventures- El Nido
7. Wildlife adventures - Phuket
Unparalleled! Elephants! Tigers!
8. Hospitality - El Nido
The warmth of Filipino hospitality is way beyond comparison. Am lost for words.
9. Tour Guide - Phuket
10. Nightlife - Phuket
Patong Beach!
11. Accessibility - Phuket
It is an international airport.
12. Affordability of hotels/accommodations - Phuket
13. Best hotels - El Nido
14. Number of airlines servicing the spot- Phuket
15. Food - El Nido
Eating in the islands. The food is prepared by the boatman himself.
16. Weather - El Nido
17. Health - El Nido
Phuket is known for AIDS.
19. Caves - Phuket
21. Hiking and mountain climbing - Phuket
23. Birdwatching - Phuket
24. Historical/City Tour - Phuket
25. Ecotourism tour - Phuket
26. Biking and Horseback riding - Phuket
27. Number of Tourist Spots - Phuket
29. Mode of transportation before you reach the beach - El Nido
30. Proximity from its capital - El Nido
31. Cost - Phuket
32. White Sand - El Nido
34. Nature photography - El Nido
35. Breathtaking view - El Nido
36. Serenity/Paradise - El Nido
37. Peace and order / Safety - Phuket
38 - Souvenir - El Nido
39. Falls - Phuket
40. Land Adventure - Phuket
41. Streetfood - Phuket
42. Sunset - Phuket
39. Falls - Phuket
40. Land Adventure - Phuket
41. Streetfood - Phuket
42. Sunset - Phuket
Total
Phuket - 23
El Nido - 19
Related links:
El Nido; http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2012/11/el-nido-adventure-of-lifetime.html
Patong Beach: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/11/patong-beach-phuket-thailand.html
Island Hopping Adventures in Phuket: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/10/island-hopping-adventure-in-phuket.html
Adventures in Thailand: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/11/adventures-in-thailand.html
Phang Nga: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/10/phang-nga-thailand-adventure-travel.html
Top 6 Lagoons in the Philippines: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/04/top-6-lagoons-in-philippines-for.html
Top 10 Beaches in the Philippines: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/04/top-10-beaches-in-philippines-ranked.html
Top 5 Island Destinations in the Philippines: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2013/03/top-5-island-destinations-for-island.html
Top 10 Favorite Tourist Spots in the Philippines:
http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2012/12/top-ten-favorite-tourist-spots-in.html
Coron v. El Nido: http://junvillegas.blogspot.com/2012/11/tourist-spots-in-palawan-which-is.html